I'm still confused, and I'm very sorry, but I feel I need to pursue this further, and I need to feel confident about my conclusion as soon as possible. Last time, about a year ago when I first had my most profound experience and didn't yet know of the GWV, i told her about it, and she sufficiently, I am embarrassed to admit, scared me into being a "taking the oath" Christian for about a week.
I foolishly, yet again, feeling confident that we were just misunderstanding each others terminology, took her terminology and explained my undetailed experiences in those terms. Because, her warnings matched up with what I've found. So, an example is that she warned the Holy Spirit is necessary for protection and guidance when exploring out of the body. I interpreted the "Holy Spirit" as the immaterial body/charisms strongest in the 4th jhana, and responded (without mentioning ANY of the terminology we use here). Now I am hesitant to read her response, because she can be very persuasive, especially since we are good friends.
A true shaman is a true mystic. In my experience with people claiming to be shaman, is most people claiming to be shaman these days have as much attainment as your average priest of any mainstream religion, which is zero. A true mystic/shaman does not need drugs. And, there is no reason why a true shaman would have to reject shamanism to be a true Christian; because, they would have had to unpack Christianity for themselves to find that mainstream Christianity is as deeply flawed as any mainstream religion.
She no longer uses drugs, although when I first began to get to know her, she invited me to bring some psych's I had. And it was a very unique experience with her, and i began to wonder if she was a shaman. It was that night which she told me she had a past with it. Her mother was there that night, and it was clear they both had a rich heritage with Native American spirituality. I can't recall her ever bashing shamanism, but I do know she is a Christian, and listens to people like Chuck Missler, which appears to be a lot of talk about "the coming of the end." His face was what flashed into my awareness before her face populated when I viewed her. And then she told me she was listening to him when I viewed her, which made sense of it all.
It is strange, because she seems to know a lot about the immaterial domains, yet she attaches to the "oath taking" kind of Christianity. I almost wonder if during her shaman years she sufficiently scared herself into attaching to a conservative Christian view.
Here is my finding on all of such spiritual fears. Once I counted as a friend a man claiming to be a shaman. One morning he came to my home with the intention of doing me spiritual harm. By then I could consistently meditate to the depth of the 4th samadhi/jhana, and had quite a bit of experience with the immaterial domains, as he had.
This shaman sat across from me and gazed into my eyes with the intent of harm. I sat in meditation at the depth of the 4th jhana, which meant I was as transparent as glass. He sat there for about an hour, then he got up and left. I only saw him one more time before he died, as I could not longer count him as friend. No harm came to me.
Now, when one begins to explore the immaterial domains one of course encounters disembodied spirits. One who is not accomplished, established in the 4th samadhi/jhana is ill prepared for the shenanigans that commonly take place there. This is why I do not emphasize the immaterial domains, OOBE, etc.; because few have mastered the 4th samadhi/jhana. Those who have I am more than happy to guide the rest of the way.
Okay, so it sounds like you are saying some people, somehow, skip jhana 1-4 and go straight to the immaterial domains? Because, it has been my experience that jhana 1-4 are precursors to the immaterial domains. At least for consistent and long-duration access.
Once one is in the immaterial domains, one is no longer in 4th jhana, correct? Well, it is possible to see the immaterial domains while in 4th jhana, but, well, I think you know what i mean. So, how does it matter that mastering 4th jhana is necessary to properly protect and navigate oneself in the immaterial domains, like 5th samadhi? I really can't catch onto this. I think it needs to be more detailed. The best guess I can make, is that somehow one will discover a disembodied spirit is trying to harm them (how?!) and then revert to the 4th jhana for protection.
And what exactly about the 4th jhana protects one from disembodied spirits "following you home?"
I just need to understand the mechanics at work here.This post is long enough as it is. I'm going to leave it at this for now, and address the rest of the responses later. But this is the main concern (above.)