This thread is more about developing a sustainable lifestyle than it is focused upon starting a whole new deeply flawed religion; however, my hope is that people will come to understand that the GWV's concept of a sustainable community/retreat center is a well reasoned sustainable community concept. This is where I am working out the concept, with input from the GWV community, so I hope that others will contribute to this discussion.
I have been focused upon understanding the hunter/gatherer lifestyle since I was 6. Then I started stockpiling camping gear and canned and dried foods for an eventual escape from the madness of my family of origin, and the rest of the insane industrialized world.
However, I have also come to learn that the hunter/gatherer lifestyle is not the only answer to the problems of human culture. Nor is migration the only answer, nor is Permaculture the only answer, nor is buying into a deeply flawed belief system the only answer.
Noenetheless, a blend of the above could work, if deep meditation were added to the model, along with a cogent and logically true belief system.
The Noble Eightfold Path describes a cogent and logically true philosophical system, which includes essentially a migratory hunter/gather lifestyle with deep meditation; however, the Buddhist priesthood have screwed it up until it is no longer a functional system.
So, if someone were to purchase a water shed on the side of a mountain, that runs from the ocean up the flank of a mountain to its peak, and offer 3 Permaculture properties in that watershed, and offer people an opportunity to live there, I am sure that person would have many takers. Let me know when when it happens and I will happily move in.
Otherwise, those without the wealth to purchase and build such a sustainable community could participate in a community of people who are working to manifest the behavioral transformation that is brought about by: living a sustainable lifestyle, subscribing to a cogent and logically true interpretation of the Nobel Eightfold Path, which includes cultivating deep meditation, and together we can all manifest a sustainable intentional community that will survive generation after generation.
It is hard to say when agriculture arrived on the scene, but archeological evidence suggests that it arrived late during the last ice age, not millions of years ago. This suggests that most humans evolved just hunting and forging.
The archeological community postulates that we, and many of the proto-human species, evolved on the savannah. I happen to disagree. I believe we evolved beach combing, and plying estuaries, swamps, tidal pools and rivers, where there is so much abundance of edible life, and the weather tends to be milder, and there are many other useful resources that it makes survival for us all too easy. For this lifestyle to work, then there had to be a significant amount of mobility, if not migration.
However, I will agree that adding the hunter-gather lifestyle to a sustainable small-scale agricultural system, such as
Permaculture, makes the small-scale agricultural system more sustainable, and more like our ecological niche, which suggests humans are going to be happier there. However, sustainable small-scale agricultural systems do not lend themselves to migration.
However, migration via jet-setting is not a definition of the hunter-gather lifestyle; nonetheless, it could be argued that many human behaviors, such as jet-setting, owe their origins in our deep evolutionary psyche.
However, the problem with humans is when they have too much time on their hands, then they start becoming neurotic, and start self-medicating their neuroses with the “seven-deadly-sins” of obsessive and compulsive behaviors.
So, postulating that all humans have to do is take on a belief system, or a lifestyle, to get away from their neuroses, has always been proven to be wrong, because it is only a partial solution. However, if a cogent and logically true philosophy/belief system is embraced, along with a sustainable lifestyle, and founded upon a contemplative life, which leads to deep meditation, then we find ample evidence for a complete lifestyle system that truly does lead toward freedom from neuroses.
Thus,
Permaculture and
feralculture are only partial solutions. Since the major religions have completely lost track of a contemplative life that leads to the cultivation of deep meditation, then they too are only partial solutions. Because humans have some deep social flaws, then any solution that does not deal with resolving those social flaws are partial solutions, and therefore are ultimately prone to failure.