Author Topic: Questions about OOBEs  (Read 11871 times)

Jhanananda

  • Administrator
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 4629
    • Great Wesern Vehicle
Re: Questions about OOBEs
« Reply #15 on: August 25, 2024, 03:17:26 PM »
It is good to know, Tad, you finished reading the book, and thank you for your report and question.  It is clear that cultural biases are used by the subjects who have NDEs and OOBEs; however, if we step back from the cultural interpretations we can see some strong similarities in these experiences, such as the god of death 'Yama' parallels the Christian devil; and the Buddha parallels the Christian Jesus. We should expect similar parallels in other religions and cultures.
There is no progress without discipline.

If you want to post to this forum, then send me a PM.

Tad

  • Administrator
  • Sr. Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 327
Re: Questions about OOBEs
« Reply #16 on: August 27, 2024, 04:10:29 AM »
Jhananda,

Good points. I think the most interesting common theme in NDEs is the light. It is interesting how the light can personalize itself even thought people generally describe it as formless and infinite. I also wonder if the light can be considered as the highest reality or if there is something even beyond it.

Jhanananda

  • Administrator
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 4629
    • Great Wesern Vehicle
Re: Questions about OOBEs
« Reply #17 on: August 27, 2024, 05:06:03 PM »
Thank you, Tad, for posing your interesting question. Certainly light is a key feature described by mystics. In my experience of the 7th stage of samma-samadhi the anthropomorphic representation of beings disappears and all beings become just points of light and love.
There is no progress without discipline.

If you want to post to this forum, then send me a PM.

Alexander

  • (Shivaswara)
  • vetted member
  • Hero Member
  • *
  • Posts: 1122
Re: Questions about OOBEs
« Reply #18 on: August 28, 2024, 11:29:42 PM »
So where is the Buddha, Jeff? Is he still “reachable” as an individual, or is he in some incomprehensible state?

What about Christ? And if Jesus is so important for millions of people, how does he meet so many in the afterlife ;D!
https://alexanderlorincz.com/

"I saw all things gathered in one volume by love - what, in the universe, seemed separate, scattered." (Canto 33)

Tad

  • Administrator
  • Sr. Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 327
Re: Questions about OOBEs
« Reply #19 on: August 29, 2024, 03:45:48 AM »
Jhanananda,

Thanks for replies and sharing experiences.


Alexander,

Good question. I am also looking forward to Jhananda's response

A Theravada monk told me that while Buddha is no longer in this universe, his energy is here until this world cycle is over. So it is possible to tap into Buddha's energy by contemplation. Maybe something similar happens in the afterlife that beings are able to see energies of various spiritual masters?

Jhanananda

  • Administrator
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 4629
    • Great Wesern Vehicle
Re: Questions about OOBEs
« Reply #20 on: August 29, 2024, 03:29:01 PM »
So where is the Buddha, Jeff? Is he still “reachable” as an individual, or is he in some incomprehensible state?

What about Christ? And if Jesus is so important for millions of people, how does he meet so many in the afterlife ;D!

The ancient enlightened beings from the deep past still exist. I know this because I have had numerous dialogs with many of them including Siddhartha Gautama and Yeshua ben David, and many others who have not entered the historic record.
There is no progress without discipline.

If you want to post to this forum, then send me a PM.

Alexander

  • (Shivaswara)
  • vetted member
  • Hero Member
  • *
  • Posts: 1122
Re: Questions about OOBEs
« Reply #21 on: August 31, 2024, 01:17:12 PM »
The ancient enlightened beings from the deep past still exist. I know this because I have had numerous dialogs with many of them including Siddhartha Gautama and Yeshua ben David, and many others who have not entered the historic record.

That is really amazing. What was the essence of what each wanted to communicate? Did the Buddha and Christ emphasize different things?

What do you make of the “God” question? Is “God” a formless impersonal divine Source like the Indians believe?

From William Buhlman’s account, it sounds like the spirit world is a thought-responsive reality. If it is, why do we reincarnate? (So, the OOB people say the purpose of life is *learning through suffering,* which is the opposite of Buddhism which teaches that we want to stop reincarnating to avoid suffering.)

How integrated are the knowledges of our different lifetimes in the post-death state? Are we able to make sense of how all our experiences caused us to grow or evolve? Is it true we “grow” in some way as a result of each life?
https://alexanderlorincz.com/

"I saw all things gathered in one volume by love - what, in the universe, seemed separate, scattered." (Canto 33)

Jhanananda

  • Administrator
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 4629
    • Great Wesern Vehicle
Re: Questions about OOBEs
« Reply #22 on: August 31, 2024, 04:27:09 PM »
That is really amazing. What was the essence of what each wanted to communicate? Did the Buddha and Christ emphasize different things?

In my experience of "communicating" in the spirit world is it is a non-verbal exchange of information, which is often times vast including the entire content of the entirety of all of their lifetimes.

What do you make of the “God” question? Is “God” a formless impersonal divine Source like the Indians believe?

The 8ths stage of samma-samadhi, in my experience, is what a mystic would experience as "god." And, "God" in my experience is the entirety of beings, which would be the "heavenly host" in a biblical context. And, at the level of the 8ths stage of samma-samadhi we become all of that in oneness.

From William Buhlman’s account, it sounds like the spirit world is a thought-responsive reality. If it is, why do we reincarnate? (So, the OOB people say the purpose of life is *learning through suffering,* which is the opposite of Buddhism which teaches that we want to stop reincarnating to avoid suffering.)

I haven't read William Buhlman, but I don't buy the spirit world is a "thought-responsive reality," or that we *learning through suffering.* Whereas, the Four Noble Truths is a far more descriptive explanation of suffering and why we reincarnate.

In my experience the various stages of the spirit world is they are all domains of delusion until we unit in unity in the 8th stage. In my experience thought comes to an end long before leaving the body.

How integrated are the knowledges of our different lifetimes in the post-death state? Are we able to make sense of how all our experiences caused us to grow or evolve? Is it true we “grow” in some way as a result of each life?

For most beings the lower spirit world, where most beings go after death, is very close and parallel to the material plane, so most spirit beings are deeply delusional, and learn nothing from lifetime to lifetime. It is only by leading a rigorous, self-aware contemplative life that cultivates the 8 stages of samma-samadhi that we "progress" to greater depths to higher domains.
There is no progress without discipline.

If you want to post to this forum, then send me a PM.

Tad

  • Administrator
  • Sr. Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 327
Re: Questions about OOBEs
« Reply #23 on: September 01, 2024, 03:03:00 AM »
Excellent questions by Alexander and very interesting replies by Jhanananda. Thanks to both.

One additional question - is the reality that you call God trying to communicate to beings in some way and help them awaken? For example, according to Buddhist texts every world cycle has a Buddha. Is not that some sort of a divine principle that Buddha's appear?

Jhanananda

  • Administrator
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 4629
    • Great Wesern Vehicle
Re: Questions about OOBEs
« Reply #24 on: September 01, 2024, 03:58:17 PM »
Excellent questions by Alexander and very interesting replies by Jhanananda. Thanks to both.

One additional question - is the reality that you call God trying to communicate to beings in some way and help them awaken? For example, according to Buddhist texts every world cycle has a Buddha. Is not that some sort of a divine principle that Buddha's appear?

This is a good question. From my experience Out-of-Body the world cycle "Buddha" is a reincarnation of the planetary deity, who is the overseer of this planet, and is in direct contact with all other planetary deities throughout the universe. And, to be clear, the "world cycles" follow the Milankovitch cycles, specifically the precession of the solstice. This also follows the movement of dominant empires, such as the movement from the age of Aries to the age of Pisces and now Aquarius.

Also, the "world cycle Buddha" is followed by angels/jinns/devas who are close associates in "orbit" around this planet. However, through attrition because the material world is so full of cruelty, abuse, and trauma, not many of these angels/jinns/devas who are close associates of the "world cycle Buddha" will be survive long enough to assist the "world cycle Buddha" in his or her work on the planet.
There is no progress without discipline.

If you want to post to this forum, then send me a PM.

Alexander

  • (Shivaswara)
  • vetted member
  • Hero Member
  • *
  • Posts: 1122
Re: Questions about OOBEs
« Reply #25 on: September 02, 2024, 10:58:08 PM »
This is a good question. From my experience Out-of-Body the world cycle "Buddha" is a reincarnation of the planetary deity, who is the overseer of this planet, and is in direct contact with all other planetary deities throughout the universe. And, to be clear, the "world cycles" follow the Milankovitch cycles, specifically the precession of the solstice. This also follows the movement of dominant empires, such as the movement from the age of Aries to the age of Pisces and now Aquarius.

Also, the "world cycle Buddha" is followed by angels/jinns/devas who are close associates in "orbit" around this planet. However, through attrition because the material world is so full of cruelty, abuse, and trauma, not many of these angels/jinns/devas who are close associates of the "world cycle Buddha" will be survive long enough to assist the "world cycle Buddha" in his or her work on the planet.

I know you have alluded to these sorts of “higher-supernatural” matters before. Is it possible to unpack these ideas, since you seem to be the only source for this info? If true, it would be invaluable to make that kind of esoteric knowledge available. Though it does make me think partly of Gurdjieff’s writings in Beelzebub’s Tales, I haven’t encountered it in other OOB writers before.

So would you agree with the following:
Does each planet have a “deity”?
Who is earth’s “deity”? The Buddha?
Does this mean non-earth planets have nonphysical beings on them?
What determines the lifespan of an angel, if it is a nonphysical being?
What is the angel’s fate at the end of its lifespan - human rebirth and amnesia?

If the devas are present how do they help us? Why don’t they try to intervene and help us more when we most need them?
Gurdjieff said the whole cosmos was evolving and earth was a branch of the “ray of creation.” He said the physical world was the most difficult part to live in of the evolving cosmos. When you speak on these matters it makes me think of this area of his teaching. Is this your experience?
Why do other OOB writers not learn these sorts of matters?

Re: planetary deities,
Where does Christ fit in?
Is there any value in a life of suffering in the “imitation of Christ”?
I also wanted to inquire into what you learned about the life of Christ when you met him?

Re: William Buhlman,
Buhlman explains some spiritual worlds to be solid “consensus realities” and others to be protean and “thought-responsive,” like the “deities who delight in creation” in Buddhism. Has this been your experience?
Buhlman suggests we want to go to the formless worlds in death, so we no longer have a human or pseudophysical form in the afterlife, is this your experience?
https://alexanderlorincz.com/

"I saw all things gathered in one volume by love - what, in the universe, seemed separate, scattered." (Canto 33)

Jhanananda

  • Administrator
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 4629
    • Great Wesern Vehicle
Re: Questions about OOBEs
« Reply #26 on: September 03, 2024, 05:03:54 PM »
Thank you, Alexander, for asking your questions.

OOBE questions answered

Does each planet have a “deity”?

Yes, each planet has a deity

Who is earth’s “deity”? The Buddha?

The planetary deities are beyond name and form (nama rupa). They have no name and no form, but when they incarnate then they take a form and are given or take a name.

Does this mean non-earth planets have nonphysical beings on them?

While life surely takes different forms on different planets and ages; nonetheless. In my experience every planet and every star has a overlord deity.

What determines the lifespan of an angel, if it is a nonphysical being?

Angels have eternal life because they are beyond material form, so they do not have a form that dies; however, when they take form, then that form is subject to genetics and events.

What is the angel’s fate at the end of its lifespan - human rebirth and amnesia?

Angels are eternal.

If the devas are present how do they help us? Why don’t they try to intervene and help us more when we most need them?

Angels and other spirit beings are all around us all of the time. We subsist in an ocean of spirit. They are always ready to help us, but they cannot modify the material world without taking birth. Sometimes they do. When angels take birth they are often demonized. When they are not, the we call them mystics. For us to acquire the aide of the angels/devas we need to learn to meditate deeply by following a righteous lifestyle, which is precisely defined by the Noble Eightfold Path.

No, evolution takes place in biology. There is no evolution in the spirit world, other than individuals learning to lead a righteous life and learning to meditate deeply, and to master the OBOE, so that they don’t have to come back to hell.

The other OBOE writers don’t write about the greater depths of the spirit world because they all reside in the lower astral which is close to the material realm.

Siddhartha Gautama and Yeshua ben David were incarnations of the planetary deity.

I don’t see any value in promoting suffering, especially when suffering is a characteristic of this domain.

The Jesus that has been hyper-marketed by the western Christian church is mostly fiction. Dump the miracles, because miracles are job security for a pretentious and hypocritical priesthood and the ruling class.

I will agree with Buhlman on one topic, at death we want to leave this world behind and never come back, because this is hell. We do that by letting go of the material world and embrace the formless domains of the spirit world.
« Last Edit: September 03, 2024, 05:05:34 PM by Jhanananda »
There is no progress without discipline.

If you want to post to this forum, then send me a PM.

Alexander

  • (Shivaswara)
  • vetted member
  • Hero Member
  • *
  • Posts: 1122
Re: Questions about OOBEs
« Reply #27 on: September 04, 2024, 10:28:42 AM »
Thank you, Jeff, for the very amazing responses to this important topic.

If you’re comfortable, and it doesn’t fatigue you, I’d like to continue asking/unpacking more of these questions.

So, from what I’ve read, it appears the spirit world is infinite, far vaster than the physical cosmos. The inhabitants of it take on all different forms, such as fairies or fey folk or nature spirits (there is a chapter of Bob Monroe’s book describing this), to celestial halls like Valhalla with beautiful cities, to even “extraterrestrial” pseudo-technological worlds as well (the latter not being my preferred place, if it exists… ;D). The Buddha also describes sex heavens with gods and nymphs, and other worlds with devas who “delight in creation,” which I always interpreted as the “thought responsive” worlds Buhlman alluded to. As a painter and writer I always found that one of the most interesting possibilities, myself. Has this wide variety of worlds been your experience?

Perhaps an odd question: given there are technological worlds, could a computer work in the spirit world? I read once about the “astral university district” where atheist souls go in death. Do they recognize they are deceased there? Do they have an “Internet” and play “local-area network” computer games with each other there? I was thinking of someone who would ask, “What is heaven without World of Warcraft?”

The other idea I have gotten from my readings, is there is an approximate hierarchy based on the jhanas, where the positive spiritual worlds are broken up by jhana 1, 2, 3, and 4, and then the very high worlds are broken up by jhana 5, 6, 7, and 8. The big difference between these is 1-4 are “form based,” for example having a human form, and 5-8 are formless, for example being a singular point of consciousness in a transcendent domain. Is this generally how it works?

In regard to devas - my conclusion is we are all actually devas once we leave the body, and that it is simply a matter of belief, knowledge, and delusion that manages us in the post-death state. So a regular person, though they have the same spiritual power of an angel, we call simply a “spirit” due to a lack of knowledge. A psychologically or spiritually ill person, we call a “ghost.” An ill-meaning and worldly person, we call a “demon.” Would you agree with this?

Previously we articulated most people’s post-death fate is a product of “like attracts like,” that the malicious, greedy, and materialistic get attracted to a similar domain, while the wise, benevolent, and transcendental get attracted to a similar domain. For instance I think of Dante who placed Socrates, Plato, and Aristotle in a similar domain, a similar-to-Earth “heaven” of the Elysian Fields. Has this been your experience?

“Angels are eternal.”
Exactly. That would be my conclusion also. So I have a few questions from this statement:
1 Would the danger thus arise in incarnation, where an angel coming to Earth develops amnesia, and has to face a life in the harsh physical world?
2 In death are you able to recall your previous lifetimes and existences, including angelic ones, and remember any previous spiritual attainment (even if, say, the world sent you astray on a worldly path)?
3 And I just want to reconcile an angel’s immortality with this statement: “However, through attrition because the material world is so full of cruelty, abuse, and trauma, not many of these angels/jinns/devas who are close associates of the "world cycle Buddha" will be survive long enough to assist the "world cycle Buddha" in his or her work on the planet.” — Are you referring to when these devas descend to Earth? Or that the devas cease working on helping alleviate human suffering and go elsewhere in the spirit world?
« Last Edit: September 04, 2024, 10:33:14 AM by Alexander »
https://alexanderlorincz.com/

"I saw all things gathered in one volume by love - what, in the universe, seemed separate, scattered." (Canto 33)

Jhanananda

  • Administrator
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 4629
    • Great Wesern Vehicle
Re: Questions about OOBEs
« Reply #28 on: September 04, 2024, 04:53:45 PM »
Thank you, Jeff, for the very amazing responses to this important topic.

If you’re comfortable, and it doesn’t fatigue you, I’d like to continue asking/unpacking more of these questions.

So, from what I’ve read, it appears the spirit world is infinite, far vaster than the physical cosmos. The inhabitants of it take on all different forms, such as fairies or fey folk or nature spirits (there is a chapter of Bob Monroe’s book describing this), to celestial halls like Valhalla with beautiful cities, to even “extraterrestrial” pseudo-technological worlds as well (the latter not being my preferred place, if it exists… ;D). The Buddha also describes sex heavens with gods and nymphs, and other worlds with devas who “delight in creation,” which I always interpreted as the “thought responsive” worlds Buhlman alluded to. As a painter and writer I always found that one of the most interesting possibilities, myself. Has this wide variety of worlds been your experience?

Yes, in my experience the nonphysical domains are infinite, and in my experience so is the physical world, so I don't buy into creationism, nor big-bangism. There is an infinite variety of experiences one can have once out-of-body; however, as long as one is engaging with anthropomorphs, then one is in the lower domains. When one is interacting with conscious, self-aware points of light and love, then one has risen to the higher domains.

Perhaps an odd question: given there are technological worlds, could a computer work in the spirit world? I read once about the “astral university district” where atheist souls go in death. Do they recognize they are deceased there? Do they have an “Internet” and play “local-area network” computer games with each other there? I was thinking of someone who would ask, “What is heaven without World of Warcraft?”

As I said, the non-physical world is infinite which means there are an infinite variety of experiences one can have, but it is all in the lower domains.

The other idea I have gotten from my readings, is there is an approximate hierarchy based on the jhanas, where the positive spiritual worlds are broken up by jhana 1, 2, 3, and 4, and then the very high worlds are broken up by jhana 5, 6, 7, and 8. The big difference between these is 1-4 are “form based,” for example having a human form, and 5-8 are formless, for example being a singular point of consciousness in a transcendent domain. Is this generally how it works?

Yes, but the 5th stage of depth in samma-samadhi is just the lower astral domains where one still embraces a kind of physical body.

In regard to devas - my conclusion is we are all actually devas once we leave the body, and that it is simply a matter of belief, knowledge, and delusion that manages us in the post-death state. So a regular person, though they have the same spiritual power of an angel, we call simply a “spirit” due to a lack of knowledge. A psychologically or spiritually ill person, we call a “ghost.” An ill-meaning and worldly person, we call a “demon.” Would you agree with this?

In my experience this is hell, which means most of the beings we encounter are demons, so when most people die they remain in the lower realms. Whereas, those who learn to meditate deeply are likely to ascend to higher domains after death, which means they will be an angel/deva after death.

Previously we articulated most people’s post-death fate is a product of “like attracts like,” that the malicious, greedy, and materialistic get attracted to a similar domain, while the wise, benevolent, and transcendental get attracted to a similar domain. For instance I think of Dante who placed Socrates, Plato, and Aristotle in a similar domain, a similar-to-Earth “heaven” of the Elysian Fields. Has this been your experience?

Yes, I agree, this has been my experience.

“Angels are eternal.”
Exactly. That would be my conclusion also. So I have a few questions from this statement:
1 Would the danger thus arise in incarnation, where an angel coming to Earth develops amnesia, and has to face a life in the harsh physical world?

Taking material form is entering hell, but angels do so regularly for the benefit of others. After death they return to the higher domains.

2 In death are you able to recall your previous lifetimes and existences, including angelic ones, and remember any previous spiritual attainment (even if, say, the world sent you astray on a worldly path)?

I would expect so, as this has been my experience of 50 years of OOBEs and many NDEs starting after my COPD diagnosis.

3 And I just want to reconcile an angel’s immortality with this statement: “However, through attrition because the material world is so full of cruelty, abuse, and trauma, not many of these angels/jinns/devas who are close associates of the "world cycle Buddha" will be survive long enough to assist the "world cycle Buddha" in his or her work on the planet.” — Are you referring to when these devas descend to Earth? Or that the devas cease working on helping alleviate human suffering and go elsewhere in the spirit world?

I'm saying their body may not survive long enough to be of much help.
There is no progress without discipline.

If you want to post to this forum, then send me a PM.

Alexander

  • (Shivaswara)
  • vetted member
  • Hero Member
  • *
  • Posts: 1122
Re: Questions about OOBEs
« Reply #29 on: September 04, 2024, 09:48:07 PM »
Thank you 🙏 , again, for the very amazing responses.  :)
https://alexanderlorincz.com/

"I saw all things gathered in one volume by love - what, in the universe, seemed separate, scattered." (Canto 33)