This is really good, Jhananda. Thank-you. Now we have something to work with, and can go into the details. I like the way you have defined some of the sets and their qualities, and your comments are helpful and thought provoking.
Over all, do the 7 sets follow a strict order or sequence of development from mindfulness culminating with the eightfold path, is there a reason for this arrangement of the sets? My guess is that you can jump in anywhere while doing the practice; it's not first you do this and then you do that.
In the suttas the arrangement seems to be only by increasing numbers. I organized them in order of, first we have to overcome our delusions, which is what the Four Noble Truths is. We have to realize that we suffer, and that there is a cause to our suffering and a path that leads to the end of suffering.
One of my sisters was a junkie for 25 years, and probably still is. She recently became a born-again, who I guess has moved onto taking junk for Jesus. She even married here heroine dealer. Now I would call this a massive denial system at play. Sadly the whole world works on such a denial system.
So, the righteous path to liberation from our addictions/sins/fetters, and spiritual enlightenment is the contemplative life, which is based upon overcoming our denial systems and becoming self-aware.
The next step in overcoming our denial systems is to take up the contemplative life, which is defined by the Noble Eightfold Path.
Overcoming our denial systems, becoming self-aware, and taking up the contemplative life is not an end in itself. The contemplative life leads, not only to liberation from our addictions/sins/fetters, and spiritual enlightenment; but it also leads to other attainments (phala), such as: the religious experience (samadhi), intuitive, revelatory insight (vipassana), OOBEs, etc. So, I organized the list of Swift Philosophies to Awakening (bodhipakkhiya-dhammá) in the order of how awakening works.
I like how you've arrived at your own title, the 37 "Swift Philosophies to Awakening." You've gone to the Pali dictionaries
Thank-you, yes, I consulted the GWV's
Contemplative's Pali-English, English-Pali DictionaryJhananda:
I think the above is Thanissaro's invention.[ The Factors of the Seven Sets classed under the Five Faculties] I could be wrong. It would be useful to have a sutta quote to unravel the knotted thread of Thanissaro's commentary.
I looked in his book and could not find a direct link to any of the suttas, but I will check again to make sure.
Just to make sure, are you referring to the 8FP as cycling over and over? Would you explain this in more detail.
No, what I meant was each section of the 37 Swift Philosophies to Awakening says almost the same thing. So, it can all be simplified as I did so in my previous response.
What do you mean by aspiration, energy, intention, investigation arising from absorption? I get that all these factors arise through the practice of jhana. But please define and explain each of these factors in detail.
A central premise that needs to be reinforced whenever possible is Jhana is not a practice (magga). It is an attainment (phala). Thus, inspiration, energy, intention, investigation are the product of absorption (samadhi), which is the religious experience. This forum is all about the fruit (phala) of attainment. There are sections on each fruit, and how they manifest. How we get there is by following a righteous path to liberation from our addictions/sins/fetters, and spiritual enlightenment through leading the contemplative life, which is based upon overcoming our denial systems and becoming self-aware.